Clinton To Introduce Legislation For Federal Gas Tax Holiday
INDIANAPOLIS, Ind — Hillary Clinton’s bashed Barack Obama again today for opposing a federal gas tax holiday over the summer — and hit her potential Republican rival John McCain for proposing one but failing to pay for it.
Clinton outlined her plan to cut the price at the pump at the Miller Veneer factory in Indianapolis — where customers have started refusing shipments because of the surcharge the company has to charge to make up for the higher cost of gas. First up in her plan: “I would immediately lower gas prices by temporarily suspending the gas tax for consumers and businesses.
“We will pay for it by imposing a windfall profits tax on the big oil companies. They sure can afford it,” she said. “This is a big difference in this race. My opponent opposes giving consumers a break from the gas tax, but I believe American people are being squeezed pretty hard.”
“There are a lot of people in Indiana who would really benefit from a gas tax holiday. That may not mean a lot to my opponent, but I think it means a lot to people who are struggling here.”
The Obama campaign called Clinton’s idea part of “The same Washington gimmicks that got us into this mess in the first place,” and circulated an article by liberal economist Paul Krugman — who is generally pro-Clinton — calling the plan “pointless, and disappointing.
Clinton, of course, disagreed. “We do need short term, immediate relief,” she said. “I’ll be introducing legislation in the congress to do just that.”
“I imagine that President Bush will be against it. Anything that goes against the oil companies you can count on the two oil men in the White House being against, that kind of is something we’ve gotten used to. But we’ve got to be prepared, and we’ve got to take the case. And we’ve got to do everything we can to try to get some changes out of congress. Then we’ve got to get really in position when finally we have a new president next January to get serious about overcoming all of our energy costs and our challenges.”
Tags: barack obama, gas, hillary clinton, indiana, john mccain
Share

Hillary is one tough and smart politico. Obama is clueless compared to Hillary.
Wow Hillary what an idea!!!! while we are at it why don’t you really do something smart and good for the country like introducing and passing legislation so we can drill in anwar. Or how about building more refineries in this country. Whats it been thirty plus years since one has been built. Oil consumption throughout the world is out of control espedially in China and India they continue to polute the environment and stick it to the United States whenever they can. But you continue to bash the Bush administration as big oil. Last time I heard Bill Clinton was still taking big fees for speaking engagements in Saudi Arabia at the tune of 500,000 dollars a speech. I wonder if he chastised the Saudi government for high oil prices. I’m sure he forgot to mention it. It’s always the good old United States fault. The world has never had the high demand of oil as it is today. When Bill was president China’s population rode bicycles. Now you can’t even breathe the air in Bejing and that poses a health risk to the athletes during the olympics. Excess cars and trucks and coal mines spewing pollutants into the atmosphere. Did I hear you say global warming Hillary? No you did’nt we are responsible for global warming . Right Hillary? When you scream to your supporters about our dependence on foreign oil think about this. If you want to drive the price of oil down quickly announce to the world that we are drilling in anwar. The oil speculators will be in a frenzy and prices will go down. But I know you won’t because the looney left of your party will abbandon you and think you are against the environment. Anwar drilling will not hurt the environment and any expert in the field will tell you that. So stop the rhetoric about a holiday gas tax relief and do something for the long term. Band aids are not the answer. A sound energy policy is. We never had one and as long as politicians use energy as a campaign issue we will never have one. Just one more thing I wonder Hillary if you are aware that millions of people have pension funds tied to oil company stock so when you continue to want to bring them down think of the millions of peoples retirements you are damaging. But once again your supporters and adoring public are naive and uneducated when it comes to these things and they are easily fooled by you. What a gimmick you have.
Hillary’s New Video Dreaming
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J52S-S1WNCA
Hillary I Won’t Back Down Video
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DIZF_ZucoFM
Hillary Waiting On The World To Change Video
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ihAguWyMIXI
Hey Ralphy your responce was pure bs. I do agree we need to build new refineries. But we need to have higher standards resulting in better fuel. My friends in the oil business tell me Anwar isn’t worth the time and effort. Besides the amount of time it would take to come on line drilling in the cold is cost prohibitive. Had you driven across the US lately you would have seen all the new wells being drilled right now. If you had any brains you realize what happens when we deregulate everything. $2 gallon gas in Mexico. Name one thing where the price went down after we deregulated it. There are some things that are better off being run by the goverment providing strict standards are met. Hillary is still the best one left in the race.
This is nothing but another cheap campaign gimmick, designed to confuse the electorate. What exactly would temporarily suspending the gas tax for consumers and businesses do to solve the underlying issues that have lead us to this point. Our overall economy is in dire straights, because gutless politicians like Hillary Clinton have failed to address problems that have been building for decades. This is true in many sectors of our economy, including energy. Not only have these so called leaders failed to act, they have first and most importantly failed in their responsibility to educate the American people. In the short term we need more refineries, and most importantly we need to reduce our dependence on hydrocarbon based fuels and develop alternative energy sources.
Hillary’s band aide approach is an example of the old politics. If you want to do something for American Families Hillary, address the real issues and while you’re at it do something to significantly reduce the property tax burden in New York State and in the rest of the country. You and your fellow members of Congress could even set aside a brief moment in your busy schedules to eliminate the use of Member Items and other forms of pork barrel spending.
RE: Comment by Mr. J
If your IQ has three digits, I would be greatly surprised! Ralph pretty much hit the nail on the head!
am a 70 year old white woman and I am really amazed at the nonentity of certian persons who keep hitting someone for someone else’s mistakes. Obama is the candidate and let’s talk about him. This is all utter distractions from fools who have nothing to offer but negative ads and stupid criticisms. This is a political election and not a church or spiritual election. Hillary and Bill have nothing to offer to this dynamic generation and so they are all out to destroy, divide and run. We talk of peace and she is on obliterating a nation! That’s evil on her part! I will not be surprised to see and hear about terror attacks on us sooner or later because of her threat over a nation! SHAME ON HER AND HER SUPPORTERS. MY SUPPORT GOES TO OBAMA FROM NOW ONWARDS. She is scary using fear to manipulate and mislead voters and you called that wisdom or being a fighter? I called it weakness, divisive, evil, witchcraft and above all a looser tactic! She has no message that is positive. What I see is that even though she lied a thousand times, her stupid and idiotic supporters call it truth. She is misrepresenting Americans in the world as a symbol of liars. If she becomes president, terrorists will wreck this nation and we will have enemies all over. DO NOT BE STUPID BY HER SILLY AND DIRTY GAMES! REAL AMERICANS ARE NOT STUPID AND IDIOTS AS DO HER SUPPORTERS!
gal,
Perhaps we’re not wise as you. Perhaps we cannot understand why we’d vote for a man endorsed by Americas enemies.
Comment by Ralph
April 30th, 2008 at 1:40 am
Wow Hillary what an idea!!!! while we are at it why don’t you really do something smart and good for the country like introducing and passing legislation so we can drill in anwar. Or how about building more refineries in this country. Whats it been thirty plus years since one has been built. Oil consumption throughout the world is out of control espedially in China and India they continue to polute the environment and stick it to the United States whenever they can. But you continue to bash the Bush administration as big oil. Last time I heard Bill Clinton was still taking big fees for speaking engagements in Saudi Arabia at the tune of 500,000 dollars a speech. I wonder if he chastised the Saudi government for high oil prices. I’m sure he forgot to mention it. It’s always the good old United States fault. The world has never had the high demand of oil as it is today. When Bill was president China’s population rode bicycles. Now you can’t even breathe the air in Bejing and that poses a health risk to the athletes during the olympics. Excess cars and trucks and coal mines spewing pollutants into the atmosphere. Did I hear you say global warming Hillary? No you did’nt we are responsible for global warming . Right Hillary? When you scream to your supporters about our dependence on foreign oil think about this. If you want to drive the price of oil down quickly announce to the world that we are drilling in anwar. The oil speculators will be in a frenzy and prices will go down. But I know you won’t because the looney left of your party will abbandon you and think you are against the environment. Anwar drilling will not hurt the environment and any expert in the field will tell you that. So stop the rhetoric about a holiday gas tax relief and do something for the long term. Band aids are not the answer. A sound energy policy is. We never had one and as long as politicians use energy as a campaign issue we will never have one. Just one more thing I wonder Hillary if you are aware that millions of people have pension funds tied to oil company stock so when you continue to want to bring them down think of the millions of peoples retirements you are damaging. But once again your supporters and adoring public are naive and uneducated when it comes to these things and they are easily fooled by you. What a gimmick you have.
_________________________________________________________________________________
>> STANDING, APPLAUDING THIS POST<<
WAY TO GO RALPH!!!!!
I posted this thought on another site…… Hillary jumped on the McCain band wagon about the gas tax holiday, but she wants to make up the revenue through higher taxes on the oil companies……call me crazy, but won’t the oil companies just pass the increase in taxes onto us through higher gas prices, making the gas tax holiday null and void?
gal.
Please tell me Obama’s qualifications to be our President.
Please list his accomplishments.
You are right, Obama and the Rev are different people.
Wright has been preaching the black agenda long before he ever met Obama.
Obama has been a devout follower of his church for 20 years.
I am surprised after all the months spent defending the rev, he now turns his back on him.
Please tell me how you view this change of heart.
fourboys.
Bingo. You are exactly right.
Hillary is also one to talk about Obama taking money from big oil companies….What about Bill’s dealings with Dubai…..Isn’t that the pot calling the kettle……stainless steel. =0)
Obama and all his corrupt friends have made this election a big joke. Our kids fighting in the
schools because of black and white. Them calling my kids “Crackers”. Saying they will burn and riot in the streets if Obama isn’t elected. It is scary and so sad. We have gone back years and years. I do not want that man or any of his followers in the White House. He is a DIVIDER. We are all voting Hillary or McCain. Please people look through all this Cult type Haze.
Why doesn’t cutting the gas tax this summer make sense? It’s Econ 101 tax incidence theory: if the supply of a good is more or less unresponsive to the price, the price to consumers will always rise until the quantity demanded falls to match the quantity supplied. Cut taxes, and all that happens is that the pretax price rises by the same amount. The McCain gas tax plan is a giveaway to oil companies, disguised as a gift to consumers. Why cant we wake up and see that this proposed break would essentialy break the back of most hard working Americans!
Oh what a wonderful idea…lets punish big oil…………..and oh, by the way with 41% of Big oil companies owned by Retirement funds and Mutuals, who gets to pay for Clinton’s “They certainly can afford it” comment. Why most average Americans, Civil Servants and Middle Class America. This disingenuous, power at all costs pollitician had the audacity to claim that she would “seize the profits of Oil Companies and do with them what SHE saw fit. Then she reacted with shock and annoyance when Halliburton declared it was moving out of the Country. You are the one who pushed them out. After declaring you would steal their profits, you then expect them to cheerfully remain and have their pockets picked by the Marxists who nowadays call themselves Democrats.
If the Phrase “Who is John Galt” is unfamiliar to you, then maybe reading Ayn Rands “Atlas Shrugged” might help you better understand the nature of the Liberal Evil spreading through this Country, and the inevitable destruction of this Nation if it is ever allowed to take hold and push forth it’s destructive, suicidal plans.
re: Comments by Mr.J
Your friends in the oil business? The nephew who pumps gas at Citgo probably won’t qualify as an expert. And anyone that believes the Government can do a better job running anything, is clearly a Big Government Liberal. Our Government and it’s perfect record makes it impossible to trust it with running anything, not even a third grade bake sale.
What a horrible idea! Making the oil companies pay the taxes only brings the promise that they will raise the price per gallon to appropriately match their desired profit margin, and then when the “holiday” ends they can keep the price per gallon and add taxes back on top of it. This effectively raises the price of gas even more. Thank you Senator Clinton. P.S. Thank you Nancy Pelosi for following through on your proposed plan to limit the price of gas that got the Dems control of the house and senate. Since they have taken over gas is up 60%!
Way to go, Hillary! Take McCain’s useless campaign gimmick and make it your own. Tell the American people you are on their side and will fight for their jobs then introduce legislation that will place 300,000 on the unemployment line. Try to convince the people you aren’t doing this for your own personal gain. While you are at it, how about explaining why you brought Tata Corporation to New York and what that move did for the people in your state?
I guess the Rev. Wright issue is a problem for Democrats and a blessing for the GOP. Watch this video and you’ll be amazed.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DXum_-8I1TA
Living on the coast and large vacation area - cutting the gas tax make sense, coastal communites depend on tourism. Also, for people who are required to drive as part of their job, it is a loss of money these days. As the gas prices continue to rise, everything in the grocery stores due, over 4.00 for milk,etc. We MUST do something and something quickly and then once in office they can go for more agressive actions on big oil companies - in the mean time everyone is suffering…it doesn’t make any difference who does this, so for gosh sakes - stopping the petty attacks on the candidates and thing about your fellow Americans suffering with this issue. Even if it is a temp fix, at least it will keep more money in your pockets for the time being. Good Job Hillary - others just talk about it and you are trying to get something done.
Yahoo!My Yahoo!MailMore
TravelFinanceEntertainmentNew User? Sign UpSign InHelp
Yahoo! NewsYahoo! News SearchSearch:Web Search
Primary Navigation
HomeU.S.BusinessWorldEntertainmentSportsTechPoliticsElectionsScienceHealthMost Popular
Secondary Navigation
Politics Video Elections White House Congress U.S. Government World Supreme Court Press Releases Search: All News Yahoo! News Only News Photos Video/Audio Advanced
——————————————————————————–
Clinton-McCain gas tax holiday slammed as bad idea By Alister Bull
1 hour, 44 minutes ago
WASHINGTON (Reuters) - A gas tax holiday proposed by U.S. presidential hopefuls John McCain and Hillary Clinton is viewed as a bad idea by many economists and has drawn unexpected support for Clinton rival Barack Obama, who also is opposed.
ADVERTISEMENT
“Score one for Obama,” wrote Greg Mankiw, a former chairman of President George W. Bush’s Council of Economic Advisers. “In light of the side effects associated with driving … gasoline taxes should be higher than they are, not lower.”
Republican McCain and Democrat Clinton, who is battling Obama for their party’s nomination, both want to suspend the 18.4-cents-per-gallon federal gas tax during the peak summer driving months to ease the pain of soaring gas prices. The tax is used to fund the Highway Trust Fund that builds and maintains roads and bridges.
Economists said that since refineries cannot increase their supply of gasoline in the space of a few summer months, lower prices will just boost demand and the benefits will flow to oil companies, not consumers.
“You are just going to push up the price of gas by almost the size of the tax cut,” said Eric Toder, a senior fellow at the Urban-Brookings Tax Policy Center in Washington.
Obama criticized the plan as pure politics and said the only way to lower the price of gas is to use less oil.
“It would last for three months and it would save you on average half a tank of gas, $25 to $30. That’s what Senator Clinton and Senator McCain are proposing to deal with the gas crisis,” he said on Tuesday in Winston-Salem, North Carolina.
“This isn’t an idea designed to get you through the summer, it’s an idea designed to get them through an election.”
This stance has prompted Clinton to accuse him of being out of touch with ordinary Americans as she campaigns ahead of key presidential nomination contests in North Carolina and Indiana on May 6.
CLINTON AT THE PUMP
The New York senator was commuting to work in South Bend, Indiana, on Wednesday and planned to pump gas at a gas station to draw attention to her plan to suspend the gas tax on consumers and businesses.
“We will pay for it by imposing a windfall profits tax on the big oil companies,” she said on Tuesday. “They sure can afford it. This is a big difference in this race. My opponent opposes giving consumers a break from the gas tax but I believe the American people are being squeezed pretty hard.”
The cost of a gallon of gasoline has touched $4 in some parts of the country as oil prices nudge toward a record $120 per barrel, hammering drivers at a time when higher food prices and falling home values are already crimping U.S. consumers.
Many economists implicitly agreed with Obama and said the McCain-Clinton gas tax plan sent the wrong signal on energy efficiency and was at odds with their pledges to combat climate change by encouraging lower U.S. carbon emissions.
“I think it is a very bad idea,” said Gilbert Metclaf, a economics professor at Tufts University currently working with the National Bureau of Economic Research.
“If we want people to invest in energy-saving cars, we need some assurance that the higher price paid for these cars is going to pay off through fuel savings,” he said. “It is a very short-sighted, counterproductive proposal.”
Economists also saw it is a poor way of getting money to the households that need it most and warned that it might end up in the cash tills of the oil companies.
“If you want to provide households tax relief, a direct rebate … is more effective. Not all of the tax relief from a gas tax holiday will be passed on to consumers. Some will likely be kept by refiners,” Mankiw said in an e-mail response.
New York Times columnist Paul Krugman was similarly underwhelmed: “It’s Econ 101: the tax cut really goes to the oil companies,” he wrote on his blog on Tuesday.
(Additional reporting by Jeff Mason in Winston-Salem, N.C., and Ellen Wulfhorst in Indianapolis)
(Editing by Bill Trott)
Email Story IM Story Printable View Yahoo! Buzz RECOMMEND THIS STORY
Recommend It:
Average (696 votes)
» Recommended Stories
Full Coverage: 2008 Presidential Election
Off the Wires
Play of the Day: Clinton visits gas station for cameras AP, 15 minutes ago Today on the presidential campaign trail AP, 20 minutes ago News Stories
GOP gives Clinton the silent treatment Politico via Yahoo! News, Apr 30 Four Michigan Dems Propose Compromise on Seating Delegation CQPolitics.com via Yahoo! News, Apr 29 Opinion & Editorials
Obama’s opportunity at The Hill, Apr 30 Landing the White Whale at The Washington Post, Apr 30 Politics News
Play of the Day: Clinton visits gas station for cameras AP Obama looks to put controversial pastor behind him AP Today on the presidential campaign trail AP New pastor to head Obama’s 8,000-member Chicago church AP GOP gives Clinton the silent treatment Politico Most Viewed - Politics
Army widens probe after finding bad conditions at Fort Bragg AP Obama looks to put controversial pastor behind him AP Fed expected to cut rates one more time AP 2 beef processors are cited for humane violations AP Obama says he’s outraged by former pastor’s comments AP Politics Video
‘Wright Posed Mortal Threat’ ABC News - Tue Apr 29, 10:01 PM ET Bush vs. Democrats on trade CNN - Tue Apr 29, 10:46 PM ET No magic wand on gas prices CNN - Tue Apr 29, 10:16 PM ET Candidate Al Franken to pay $70K in back taxes AP - Tue Apr 29, 9:55 PM ET
Sponsored Links( What’s this? )
No Time for School? Graduate Online
Get a Degree in as Few as 2 Yrs- Graduate Faster with Online Classes.
http://www.ClassesUSA.com Refinance $300,000 for Only $965/Month
$300,000 Mortgage for only $965/month. Save $1,000’s - No obligation.
http://www.HomeLoanHelpLine.com Online College Programs - US Residents
Get matched with up to 5 colleges with 1 form. Serious inquiries only.
http://www.NexTag.com/online-degrees Related Video
How candidates spell relief
CNN
Poll: Clinton narrows gap on Obama
WRAL Raleigh
» All news video
Reuters Photo: A customer pumps gas at a Shell gas station in Cambridge, Massachusetts April 29, 2008…. Elsewhere on the Web
Politico: Obama backer predicts victory in Hill war
ABC News: Obama Pivots off Wright Episode
McClatchy Newspapers: Clinton blasts Bush for not stopping a project her husband approved
Election 08
Debating game
Clinton wants a debate not to talk issues, but because it fits her strategy.
Democrats souring on the ‘other’ candidate
McCain moves to middle on health care
N.C. governor gives big boost to Clinton
News coverage from your state
See the delegate count and latest polls
ADVERTISEMENT
Add headlines to your personalized My Yahoo! page
(About My Yahoo! and RSS)
Race for ‘08 - Hillary Clinton
Add to My Yahoo! Add to RSSRace for ‘08 - John McCain
Add to My Yahoo! Add to RSSRace for ‘08 - Barack Obama
Add to My Yahoo! Add to RSSElections Wires
Add to My Yahoo! Add to RSS» More news feeds
NEWS ALERTS
Get an alert when there are new stories about:
Highway Trust Fund
windfall profits tax
s Council of Economic Advisers
federal gas tax
Tax Policy Center
» More alerts
——————————————————————————–
Yahoo! - My Yahoo! - Mail
Search: All News Yahoo! News Only News Photos Video/Audio Advanced
Primary Navigation
Home U.S Business World Entertainment Sports Tech Politics Science Health Travel Most Popular Odd News Opinion
Copyright © 2008 Reuters Limited. All rights reserved. Republication or redistribution of Reuters content is expressly prohibited without the prior written consent of Reuters. Reuters shall not be liable for any errors or delays in the content, or for any actions taken in reliance thereon.
Copyright © 2007 Yahoo All rights reserved.Copyright/IP Policy |Terms of Service |Help |Feedback
NOTICE: We collect personal information on this site. To learn more about how we use your information, see our» Privacy Policy
This is a great idea!!!
Why stop with the oil companies….We can also go after the “wind fall” profits of pharmaceutical companies…which the last time that I looked, were 2.5 times what the oil companies are making…to pay for a national health care plan. Then we can take the “wind fall” profits of Microsoft and Apple to finance public education….the possibilities are endless!!!.
Obama, Clinton, and McCain are getting alot of questions about high gasoline prices.
TV news people are talking about possible $4/gallon gas this summer.
Environmental extremism has alot to do with these high prices.
Global Warming is a hoax and a false religion the roots of which come from some liberal political groups
hatred of capitalism and freedom and modern life as we know it for polluting the world and the
atmosphere and a false belief that this is causing worldwide climate change.
Most rational minded scholars, scientists and meteorologists do not share this radical politically motivated
view of climate change and make a convincing scientific argument against it.
Lawsuits filed by so-called environmentalists against every effort by energy providers to bring
fuel to market have driven up consumer prices to record levels and will go even higher.
Please understand that you can combat this trend by becoming educated on this subject and demand
that politicians denounce Global Warming and put a stop to dangerous environmental extremism
and environmental lawsuits against energy providers. Do a Google search on Global Warming Debunked
to get started. Write letters to your school board and let them know you don’t want your children
indoctrinated with only one side of the global warming debate. Democrats attack energy providers
for making a profit instead of admitting their own extreme and false environmental ideology is
the true cause of todays high costs of doing business. Democrats are against oil, natural gas,
coal, and nuclear energy development in our own country. Make no mistake about it, Democrats
are enemies of energy producers and the buck stops at their desks for our current economic situation.
Please keep this and the price of your fuel in mind when voting this November.
http://store.nicenecouncil.com/index.php?main_page=product_info&products_id=427
Compared to Hillary, Obama is COMPLETELY USELESS.
When will this A-$$*HOLE DROP OUT??
Put a stop to the GLOBAL WARMING HOAX and extreme environmentalism
and fuel will be less expensive and abundant.
Global Warming Hysteria is putting the brakes on energy development and adding great costs
to energy development in the form of lawsuits against energy related initiatives and negative
PR. Organic TieDye Hippie Dreams are not going to provide for our energy needs in the emerging
world. We need OIL, NATURAL GAS, COAL, NUCLEAR.
The time has come to put a stop to the GLOBAL WARMING FANTASY for the good of all people.
Al Gore is a liar, a fool, and a very destructive force on the political scene today.
Let’s put Al Gore where he belongs……..in the garbage dump of enemies of mankind.
You will not get cheaper fuel from Hillary attacking energy providers.
You will not get more abundant supplies of energy from democrat anti-energy policies.
http://store.nicenecouncil.com/index.php?main_page=product_info&products_id=427
Sen Clinton is promising a gas tax cut but Obama says no. She is promising a “holiday” relief now, so that we can pay(nightmare) for it in the end. If we take the gas tax cut, we would be taking away from monies used for our streets, roads and bridges, (remember the bridge in Minneapolis that collaspe?) The oil companies will not suffer, they will just hike the prices even more. So, do we target a plan for the oil company dudes to be mandated to lower the cost of gas, or pacify us now, and make us pay later?
Comment to Mr. J
More government control on energy? You must be kidding. Show me where the government can run anything efficiently. Free markets take care of themselves it is called supply and demand. The demand is extremely high and will continue to be for the near future. You mention 2.00 a gallon gas in Mexico as your example . If you bother to research this you wouldn’t even use rthis as your so called proof government works better. The system is corrupt and going broke last time I checked. They also don’t have the same environmental restrictions like we do that drives the price through the roof. Do you have any idea how many different mixtures of gas there are in California alone? A t least twenty last count. That’s government control for you . If you remember and I am sure you don’t that after hurricane Katrina hit the president issued an executive order to suspend all the different mixes to speed up the refining of gasoline.And what happened was prices went down . That is an option I wish he would do now. So before you call my point of view Bs do your homework and get your facts straight. Your blinding partisanship gets in the way of common sense. Let me end this by listing some government run successes for you. Social security, Veterans administration, welfare, medicare just to name a few. Real successes aren’t they?
Why all the hoop-la about Hilary proposing a holiday from the gas tax? John McCain suggested that 2 weeks ago and now people are acting as if it is a new idea
McCain And Hillary are soft pedalling this gas price issue.
Gas prices are more than a dollar per gallon more than last year. Gas company profits are soaring. Why Hillary and McCain can’t put this together escapes me. Everybody know that Bush is in bed with the Gas companies. The Bush family is robbing this country a gallon at a time.
I can sort of understand McCain’s position. He needs the Bush supporters to win the election, so he will not propose anything substanial that will hurt his chances in getting that support.
It seems like Hillary recognizes that the Republicans would rather face her than Obama, therfore see seems to think that in order to fulfil here destiny, she will even side with the Republicans.
You Hillary supporters need to ask yourself why the Republicans would rather go up against Hillary instead of Obama.
If Obama were the weaker candidate, I woud think the Republicans would rather go up against him.
Seems hilliary or Mccain or actually no one can say anything about obama or run any ad pointing
out his stance and differences, without obama dismissing it without explaining what he would do
I believe we should just crown him now, we don’t need to know what he stands for except change
We could all use the $50 we we would save if the tax was suspended for 3 months!!!!!!!!
Recently, John Hofmeister, president of Shell Oil Co., the U.S. division of Royal Dutch Shell said,
“the U.S. set a goal to produce 2 to 3 million barrels more a day in this country, we would send a shock around the world that would immediately say to the speculators, hey, U.S. is serious.”
I doubt that the US would benefit that much. Most of the oil consumption in the future is going to go to China and India, so unless we regulated it better, our oil would also go there, Shell oil is a Dutch company, not a US company.
We should produce more oil and mandate that excess profits go to alternative energy and our problems would be solved sooner than later.
Look at what already happened to corn as a fuel alternative, pushed by congress, now realized as not cost effective and we have to start all over again. Our government already Subsidizes the oil industry which allows them to have record profits and subsidizes farmers not to grow crops.
Comment by Ralph
April 30th, 2008 at 12:34 pm
Comment to Mr. J
More government control on energy? You must be kidding. Show me where the government can run anything efficiently. Free markets take care of themselves it is called supply and demand. The demand is extremely high and will continue to be for the near future. You mention 2.00 a gallon gas in Mexico as your example . If you bother to research this you wouldn’t even use rthis as your so called proof government works better. The system is corrupt and going broke last time I checked. They also don’t have the same environmental restrictions like we do that drives the price through the roof. Do you have any idea how many different mixtures of gas there are in California alone? A t least twenty last count. That’s government control for you . If you remember and I am sure you don’t that after hurricane Katrina hit the president issued an executive order to suspend all the different mixes to speed up the refining of gasoline.And what happened was prices went down . That is an option I wish he would do now. So before you call my point of view Bs do your homework and get your facts straight. Your blinding partisanship gets in the way of common sense. Let me end this by listing some government run successes for you. Social security, Veterans administration, welfare, medicare just to name a few. Real successes aren’t they?
*****************************************
OH I GET YOUR POINT OF VIEW NOW RALPH
MORE CONTROL FOR AND BY LARGE CORPORATION BECAUSE THEY KNOW HOW TO RUN AN ORGANIZATION AND AFTER ALL WHAT IS A COUNTRY BUT A MEGA-BUSINESS CONGLOMERATE, AND BECAUSE GOVERNMENT HAS BEEN DOING SUCH A LOUSY JOB.
CORPORATIONS EARN TRILLIONS OF DOLLARS IN PROFITS WHILE GOVERNMENT WASTE TRILLIONS OF DOLLARS ON SOLICAL CONCERNS AND WARS, WHAT DOES IT MATTER THAT THE ORIGINAL MONIES COME FROM THE TAXES OF CITIZENS….
IT IS SO EASY TO BE GLIB AND TO RANT CERTAIN PERSPECTIVES WITHOUT ANY WORTHY SOLUTIONS OR CONCLUSIONS….
OH SO EASY LOOK HOW WELL REV. J. WRIGHT DOES IT!
Uh, excuse me. Didn’t John McCain propose this FIRST? Now Clinton jumps on the bandwagon and makes it look likes it’s her idea. Next, Barack will be giving out free gas cards with the leftover millions in his campaign fund (illegal money donated from his indicted crook friend in Chicago).
Comment to An american in Canada
I am not quite sure what you are trying to say. If you are refering to me as ranting and not offering sollutions you need to read my earlier comment. Also where does the Wright comment come from? He is an out of control pastor who’s views I do not share. By the way how is Canada treating you these days?
We need Bill Gates for President. He knows how to handle the economy, would squash the buffoons in Washington because he doesn’t need to kiss ass, and he wouldn’t give away our money to stinking ungrateful ragheads across the ocean.
Now, can someone tell me what has obama proposed to reduce gas price and turn some savings to the american people??
He only criticized Mccain’s and Hillary’s plan. But offer no proposal of his own. ZERO!
Oh.. I forgot. His proposal is telling folks to use less gas. This is pretty much NOTHING.
Its like if a person approach him say food prices are too high, he’s unable to afford to feed his family. Obama will tell him - EAT LESS FOOD. Problem solved!!!
So we are back to square one - The discussion on Wright, Ayers, etc…
John,
Gas prices are REAL issues.
Wright and Ayers are distractions and continues down the road of personal attacks.
The discuss should be on issues NOT personalities.
Carol, john mccain didn’t know how to pay for it. Just like the iraq war, he wants to give the iraqi government a blank cheque for them to drag their feet to come to reconciliation. But where is he going to get money from to finance this in-fighting between the different iraqi factions?
This nation cannot keeps on throwing good money and life for the Iraqi people.
The iraq war is the main reason this country is going bankrupt, and the dollar sinking to all time low, which causes the oil price to sky rocketed to records levels not seen before.
If mccain wants to carry on bush iraq’s policy, he should run for president in the next Iraqi presidential election.
Michael in Atlanta
First off, I think obama is UNFIT to be running for president because he has fundamental character flaw. Its really TOO LATE for him to save himself now, however he spins it, or acts in front of the camera for votes. His “changing washington” credibility is already gone, and he can only blamed himself for it.
Anyway, my point obama has really NOTHING to offer. Hence the discussion of the “distractions” and his associating with the wrong kind of people in his political career.
Comment to fourboys
You hit the nail on the head. The consumer will get hammered even more when the tax holiday is done. All it is is a campaign gimmick for the uninformed public who Hillary preys on.
I do not claim to have extensive knowledge of the “oil business” as some of the bloggers have professed to… whether the ’summer tax’ plan will work or not iss still questionable but what I do appreciate is the fact that someone is actually thinking of ways to reduce this horrible situation… finally someone has stepped up to the challenge….
Now, in California - the oilcompanies (who continue to reap BILLIONS in windfall profits per month) have started an ad campaign AGAINST the “windfall tax”… they obviously do NOT want to reduce their money into their pockets… the US is just seeing the hike in gas - this has been in Europe for years and we are just now catching up… this IS a world wide issue and not just the US… so it is the Oil Companies behind this and not the issue of drilling in the US (Alaska to be exact)…let’s just ruin another state and destroy an ecological life left on this planet. Way back, if my memory serves me well - the oild companies lobbied for tax breaks etc. so they could fund new exploration for oil and for new alternative energy to be used and they said they would be able to keep our rates down by getting this break….they said they need money to do this??? Now, what the **((&&^$#&%^&*%^ are they doing with all that BILLIONS IN PROFIT REPORTED BY ALL THE OIL COMPANIES???? Not
using it for what they lobbied for… this IS clear…. so now the new objective is “don’t penalize us for making profits or taking away anything we already had ; the only solution is to open up the ability to drill anywhere in the US and we of course need more money to do this…
I don’t buy it… the oil companies are a huge lobby…and each of the candidates has received their fair share of donations some more than others… some make claims of not taking money from them even though it is illegal to do so anyway… some forget to mention that the oil company executives, etc. contribute LARGE sums of money to their campaigns… http://www.judicialwatch.org/blog/obama-lies-about-oil-money
What I want and need from the senators, congressional members (all of them) IS to get off your lazy A** and earn your keep… do something productive and stop the mass profiting and protect the people you are suppose to represent… it is so easy for all the candidates to “speak and blame” but has anyone of them actually done anything - anything? your all senators… earn your keep!!!
Also, what I have noticed recently is a lot of “elderly white people” blogging in this forum… when you read their messages it is so much like the ones that used to be issued by the regular obama supporters… I guess this is a new technique …
by the way I am an “elderly black man”…. supporting Clinton or Mc Cain…
So one must ask Mr Obama which is worse; Pandering to voters telling them your going to reduce their pain at the pump, or Pandering to voters, getting elected to the Senate by telling them you’re going to end an illegal, ill-concieved, immoral, and unjust war, then go on to hold out for two years giving the same promise in an attempt to outswindle a path to the Presidency?
I’ve said before this is a stupid idea for many reasons. But not only is it economically stupid… it is just.. stupid. There is no windfall profits tax Regan got rid of that years ago, Bush isn’t going to sign into law new taxes. So her plan is basically putting the carriage before the horse (which we’ll all be riding if this were to actually pass, and gas companies just raise the prise of gas both because we are increasing demand without increasing supply and because they’re not going to take pay cuts, they’ll just raise the gas price to pay for their higher tax rate) But its cute politics and it’ll fool a couple people. There’s always a politician who calls for this when its election time.. Bob Dole did it too.
John,
There are a lot of reason why we choose to vote for one candidate or the other. Conservatives like to divert discussion about issues to something else because they know they have been wrong on the issues. Conservatives don’t care about issues. They just want their guy to win, no matter what.
Conservatives really do like John McCain. They have had to settle.
I am voting for Obama for one issue and one issue alone. The IRAQ war.
As I as I respect John McCain, he is wrong about the war. We have been the too long. We have wasted enough of our troops. We are wasting our tax dollars. John McCain only supports this war because he is embarrassed by his party’s handling of the war and wants to make good on a bad situation..
Conservatives really do NOT like John McCain. They have had to settle.
Comment by Ralph
April 30th, 2008 at 1:10 pm
Comment to An american in Canada
I am not quite sure what you are trying to say. If you are refering to me as ranting and not offering sollutions you need to read my earlier comment. Also where does the Wright comment come from? He is an out of control pastor who’s views I do not share. By the way how is Canada treating you these days?
************************
CANADIANS LOVE AMERICANS AND THEY WORRY ABOUT AMERICA’S INTERNAL ENEMIES SUCH AS WRIGHT, AYERS, ET AL…
THEY ARE ALSO AMAZED AT THE BLACK RACISM THAT AFRICAN-AMERICAN HAVE TOWARD THEIR FELLOW AMERICANS….
ALTHOUGH TRUTH BE TOLD EVERYONE IS A BIT RACIST BUT NOT TO THE POINT OF HATRED TO OTHER RACES MORE LIKE PROUD OF THEIR RACE, SUCH AS THE IRISH, ITALIANS ETC…
IN THAT RESPECT YOU CAN SAY MOST PEOPLE ARE RACIST IN A GOOD SENSE.
PLEASE stop all the talk about “RACE”.
It by it’s nature is divisive.
In a country where ALL me are created equal, “RACE” should not be a factor.
One can only guess as to why Fox News and the like keeps trying to make this election about “RACE”
Really, too much wasted time talking about this issue. Congress, take action NOW. You’ve had the house for how long now??? I thought you left leaning loonies would come up with something better than TAX AND SPEND.
Michael in Atlanta…………….it’s not about race………….it’s about anti-American’s surround’s themselves with like type people and saying you want CHANGE. CHANGE at my expense. Going to try and make sure that never happens.
McCain 08
I AM ABSOLUTELY AMAZED AT HOW MANY PEOPLE EITHER CAN’T SEE THAT HILLARY WILL SAY OR DO ANYTHING TO GET ELECTED - OR THEY DON’T CARE!!! EVERYTHING SHE IS UP TO RIGHT NOW IS CALLED “PANDERING”!! THAT IS ALSO KNOWN AS TELL THEM WHAT THEY WANT TO HEAR SO YOU CAN DO WHAT YOU WANT! SHE WANTS THE NOMINATION SO SHE’LL TELL YOU OR PROMISE YOU ANYTHING TO GET IT!! ARE WE THAT GULLIBLE? HAVE WE SO SOON FORGOTTEN WHY WE DIDN’T LIKE HER JUST A FEW WEEKS AGO?
WAKE UP PEOPLE BEFORE WE SQUANDER THE BEST OPPORTUNITY WE’VE HAD IN DECADES!
“Typical White Person” shut up its your stupid party that got us into this mess were in. Most economist believe this war will cost us somewhere between 1-2 trillion dollars which would be 10-20% of the Nation Debt.
Second this “Tax Holiday” is a joke because Hillary knows she’s losing this race and is trying to throw out gimmick ideas that will hurt the average american, but she doesn’t care about that as long as she gets elected. Lastly the stupid Wright situation needs to stop if this is all you have on Obama then this race should already be over. This is the problem with politics, this has nothing to do with how good of a leader Obama would be.
WAY TO GO JEFF X.
Obama has endorsements from all of America’s terrorist enemies! His friend Jimmy Carter is trying to get in bed with them now.
I hope Congress and the House pass the bill to take all of Carters millions in donations annually for his center in Georgia! He went against the will of America!
Obama will do the same. He’s already said in a national debate that he would get friendly with the Cubans